Sunday, May 16, 2010

Solitaire - Neil Sedaka (1972)



In 1972, Neil Sedaka released the album "Solitaire" in the UK. The title song has gone on to have a rather interesting history.

I first came across it on Sedaka's '75 US release, "Sedaka's Back", which also had his hit Laughter in the Rain and his original version of the Captain and Teneille hit Love Will Keep Us Together, but at that point it had already seen success when it was covered by both Andy Williams and The Carpenters. Elvis Presley even managed a version not long before his death.

It's a melodramatic song, but in the right hands rather powerful. I always liked Sedaka's original version, though. Karen Carpenter's read of the opening verse is spectacular, but this strength is somehow lost through the rest of the song.

Musically, vocally, it's an interesting song. It's a not bad lyric (though the lyric can vary considerably between different artists' versions), and while the melody gives the performer the chance to deliver a powerful vocal, the song suffers if it's overdone. Interestingly, Clay Aiken used it when he competed on American Idol on season two, and it was considered by many his best performance in the competition. Sedaka himself told Aiken it was now "your song".

Labels: ,